0
votes

Multiculturalism and You

posted September 13, 2006 - 8:19pm
Multiculturalism and You

The United States of America. Think of what that phrase means to you. Think of what it means to the world. Say it again if you need to. It's the greatest nation in the history of the world. We consider ourselves the "melting pot" of the earth. "Melting pot" was used to describe the social assimilation of many different ethnic groups into the American culture in the early 1900's. Immigrants wanted to come to America to enjoy the freedoms and opportunities our citizens are born into. They were optimistic about their future here and were proud to be called Americans. They left the "old world" behind and were eager to contribute to their new country, a vast and prosperous land known as the United States of America.

In the nineteenth century, immigrants traveled here from abroad to learn our history and our language, and not only to accept our way of life, but to excel at it. Today, it's hard to find an immigrant that wants to do all of that. One of our great presidents, Teddy Roosevelt, began to see a new development in the immigrant communities in the early twentieth century. He saw waves of immigrants take advantage of our opportunities, but not try to assimilate into our culture. He had very strong opinions about people who called themselves "Irish-Americans" or "German-Americans." He felt that those who wanted to be hyphenated Americans and those who showed allegiance to their native country did not belong here. But nowadays, it is widely accepted and almost demanded that you call people "Asian-American" or "African-American." Roosevelt believed that this mentality would lead our nation to ruin.

In our public schools across the nation, multiculturalism is thought to be a noble subject of great importance for our children to learn. Meanwhile, students aren't learning basic American history. They couldn't tell you what Seward's Folly was, or who shot William McKinley. In some communities in the southwestern states, school children are taught American history form textbooks provided by the Mexican consolate which teach from the viewpoint of Santa Anna, who believed we stole that land from Mexico. This multicultural, political correctness results in the "reconquistador" mentality in the southwest. They aren't taught what it means to be an American, especially children of immigrants who grow up in their own ethnic communities, speak their native language, and practice their native customs day in and day out. We're supposed to just accept the fact that many immigrants don't consider themselves Americans. They don't want to assimilate and don't feel they have to, then complain when they feel they're discriminated against because they can't compete in a work force outside their community. They don't have a sense of pride for this country, and it's a main contributor to our population's lack of patriotism.

Millions of immigrants have come to this country to live a better life and to do things they would never have a chance to do in their native land. We are constantly told that not only can we not criticize their choice to not assimilate, but WE must adapt to THEM in order for them to feel accepted. I say, to hell with that! I'm fed up with immigrants coming here and taking advantage of our capitalism and government grants, which many native-born Americans can't receive, and never taking the time to learn a damn word of english. They want to be involved in the political process, but can't read a ballot. They want to criticize our government's laws and policies with no understanding of our history. Instead of flying Old Glory, they hang the flag of their "motherland" in their rear-view mirrors and in front of their houses. What's the point of immigrating to this country if you're not going to become an American?

In 1915, Teddy Roosevelt stated the following in an address to the Knights of Columbus in New York City:

"Americanism is a matter of the spirit and of the soul. Our allegiance must be purely to the United States. We must unsparingly condemn any man who holds any other allegiance. But if he is heartily and singly loyal to this Republic, then no matter where he was born, he is just as good an American as anyone else."

Where is the spirit and loyalty in today's immigrants? Where is this spirit being taught in today's schools? Our country cannot continue to be divided by cultural boundaries and cannot be held hostage by activists who preach political correctness. We are supposed to be one nation. We're supposed to be one culture. We're supposed to be patriots. We must be Americans first, before we can succeed at anything else. We must teach naturalized and native-born citizens alike, the culture of America and what it means to be an American.

"We are a nation, not a hodge-podge of foreign nationalities. We are a people, and not a polyglot boarding house." - T.R.



Comments

So you don't like new America? TOo bad, get used to it

Thank you Lysandra - some people on this comment thing think that this is the first time this problem has ever been THIS serious. They think the country is the worst its ever been...tisk tisk. Ever since Adam and Eve got kicked out of the damn gardenits been the end of days and every year has been worse then the last. Where just ona downwarding spiral away from heaven or Edan or whatever and the second coming of Christ has been right around the corner for the last 2000 years. Its all fear and fear of change. That's all I hear when I read that people think the country is headed for disaster. American Haters living in American borders - Accept it cus you change people hearts. The Times they are A Changin Bob Dylan Come gather 'round people Wherever you roam And admit that the waters Around you have grown And accept it that soon You'll be drenched to the bone. If your time to you Is worth savin' Then you better start swimmin' Or you'll sink like a stone For the times they are a-changin'. Come writers and critics Who prophesize with your pen And keep your eyes wide The chance won't come again And don't speak too soon For the wheel's still in spin And there's no tellin' who That it's namin'. For the loser now Will be later to win For the times they are a-changin'. Come senators, congressmen Please heed the call Don't stand in the doorway Don't block up the hall For he that gets hurt Will be he who has stalled There's a battle outside And it is ragin'. It'll soon shake your windows And rattle your walls For the times they are a-changin'. Come mothers and fathers Throughout the land And don't criticize What you can't understand Your sons and your daughters Are beyond your command Your old road is Rapidly agin'. Please get out of the new one If you can't lend your hand For the times they are a-changin'. The line it is drawn The curse it is cast The slow one now Will later be fast As the present now Will later be past The order is Rapidly fadin'. And the first one now Will later be last For the times they are a-changin'. --Sue

Unhappy Immigrants are going to ruin this country...somehow..

This is the best argument you have made so far. FOr once I feel like we are on the same page. I understad your concern, but at the same time I don't see how this problem is any more severe then 100 years ago and why all of a sudden NOW our country is in trouble. Look at New York - thriving - and it has China Town and Little Italy and so forth. In fact go back to the 1600s and you will find whole providences that were completely German, Massechusettes all English. People group together out of fear and for comfort. Who judges what is American adn what is unAmerican. SOme people accuse left wing liberals of being unAmerican, three years ago those that didn't support the war were considered unAmerican, and now people who don't learn English and smile all day thinking to themselves "this place is the bestest everest!" are unAmerican? Well, who decides what is and what isn't? If you decide it then a large majority of this country is unAmerican - and if that is the majority maybe that IS what Amercans are and what they are about and maybe what you fear isn't that the country is in trouble because people won't conform to basic cultural standards but that those cultural standards are changing. Just trying to figure out what makes this problem so much more severe then it has been in the last 200 years that NOW our country is suffering and in danger of some sort...umm I'm still unsure of what that danger is. _Sue

My only question is, does

My only question is, does anyone have some historical time or place in mind where people did not hate and persecute one another? Some Eden where the majority of people were not primarily interested in sex, money, and keeping up with the Joneses? Societies of old were almost always small, xenophobic, conformist, dogmatic. (Not to say they did not care for and take care of one another. That tight sense of community is what maintains the American small town, like my own hometown, though that is fast changing in the modern age.) What I mean to say is, there was never a golden American age of mixing/melding/melting. It was the ideal when we were founded and it is the ideal today. And some areas of the country have been better at it than others. But the America of yore was often even MORE embattled -- think New York City in the late 19th/early 20th century, when European immigrants fresh off the boat faced hostile "natives" whose ancestors had immigrated two hundred years before -- and when its ethnic groups weren't fighting, it wasn't because they were melting together peacefully but because they lived so far apart.

You had me until you started

You had me until you started babbling about prophecy. Nothing is set in stone, there is always hope. America can still become the great country is was meant to be once again. And, come on, native americans might get trampled on these days, but they have the last laugh in the casino. I hope you have enough native in you to not pay taxes, I wish I did.

I'm native so your argument

I'm native so your argument is null. Both Native American and native American. My ancestors were on BOTH sides of the thanksgiving feast. And please, Confucius, leave your trite, fortune-cookie insults on the cuttingroom floor before you post.

If you haven't experienced

If you haven't experienced immigrants that do not want to assimilate into american culture then you need to get out to big cities more often. They create little societies for themselves so they can function without learning english or any of our customs. And the following isn't speculation, this is what I've been told. Many current immigrants come over here purely to give their children more opportunity. They were doctors and well-respected professionals in their countries and now they work crappy jobs because they can't communicate well enough to perform their previous jobs over here. So they're miserable in the process, and therefore they cling to a happier time, time in their homeland, and that culture. But that culture didn't work or else they wouldn't be here and trying to preserve it over here won't either. I don't know who David Levinsky is, but these people can afford to leave, but don't want to. If they stay, they need to become americans, not just on paper, but in spirit, or else our country is in serious trouble.

That ain't a comment; it's a tome.

Whoa, you didn't just jump into the fray; you did a high-flying cannonball!

Antonia Dwells

Jumping into the fray here

Jen Donier Whew! Ok let's see, My Native American INDIAN part says your all foreigner's and all you Euro-Asian-Latino-African-Americans ETC. Had no respect for the people who were first. And many still don't. You all came here to our land and imposed your belief's, traditions and will on the American Indian, even the name you gave us is foreign. Because good ole Christopher Columbus got lost and didn't know who the people were here in this huge land of opportunity for so many. My Euro-American side says well we are old, way back to the revolution and Dan'l Boone and all. When George become President, followed by John Adams, Tom Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, John Q. Adams, Andrew Jackson also known as Ole' Hickory etc. etc. If you all admitted to the real truth and anyone of our American fore-father's who came to settle this nation and make it great. NONE of us today here in modern day America have any right alluding to what they "meant" or changing the constitution to take away anyone's freedoms or rights. As to speaking English that was settled way way back too I would have to look up the actual date but it was between our nation speaking German or English. English won. But that law is not enforced. Everyone is afraid to offend someone else. "Politically correct" is plain stupid. I am watching John Stosel tonight on 20/20 and Wow none of us are truly one bit politcally correct and should not have to be. "Freedom of speech" meant exactly what our forefather's intended it to. But today's society gets all hot under the collar over every little stupid thing. I was born an American I am proud to be an American. I am not Euro-American, African-American, Asian-American, Latino-American or even Native American. I would like to be just American no matter what nationalities flow through my veins from my ancestors. Who care's. They don't. I don't. As to religion again one was supposed to be able to come and worship and practice one's beliefs. But that did not last very long as someone in this hot debate pointed out. Euro-Americans started preaching at the American natives right off the bat at how pagan they were. People do not respect one another, love one another or accept one another's value's any more. Our education system is in the toilet. Our kids are dummied down. The big push is MONEY! Anything to make money at anyone's expense at any cost. Greed. Mohammed, Christ etc would be ashamed. Abraham was not Muslim, he was not Jew, he wasn't even Israelite. He was HEBREW! from the land of UR! He fathered both the Muslims and the Israelites. BTW for anyone who wants to know. a Jew is an Israelite. But not all Israelites are Jews. Most of Israel was scattered. Throughout all the nations, lost so to speak, sold into captivity over and over again. You might be Israelite and not even know it. Our schools are atrocious, the teachers are not teaching kids, they are in it mostly for the money. The kids going are interested in the newest fashion, music, their peers, Hollywood icon, sex and drugs. The parents are interested in sports, feel good, whats hot, money, more money, sex and drugs and upscaling your neighbor. Pathetic. Hatred is rampant and alive and well in America. The Home of the Brave, the Land of the Free. One nation under God. yeah right. We are no longer united, have not been for a very long time and everyone knows it. No one is mixing or melting. Not like they used to. America is thought of today as a place to get rich by other nations, and many do NOT come to work but come here for a free hand out, welfare check, education, and now soon social security, to have a child here so they can claim citizenship through the child. Selfish. And the most spit on used, trampled on, hated people in America are the ones who were here first. The American Indian. You took away our way of life and put us on reservations. Taught your English to our young etc. You know the song. Cherokee People or Absorka, Or Comanche, Or Apache, or Shoshone, Nootka, Spokane, Colville, Sioux, Blackfoot. But hey it was bound to happen and prophecy is still being fulfilled and your all part of including the decline and fall our the good Old USA. We are destroying ourselves daily. We go into other nations and demand they live by our beliefs, standards and customs. And wonder why they hate us. We don't take care of our own, hungry, poor, homeless, sick or needy. America is going down and the people destroying it is Americans no matter where your ancestrial roots are. And this debate is just one more nail in it's coffin. The End!

Celanith

Hello everyone, stop and set awhile.

I liked reading your

I liked reading your perspective, Pub. All the commentary on it is like an out-of-control wildfire. It's amusing, largely inconsequential. Thanks for starting that one.

Antonia Dwells

let me join the fray to say --

Ken - it appears to me that you have a great deal of general anger and limited imagination. You are very righteous and proud about your God-given place as an American. Good for you. Where did your people come from? Do you think when they came over, they had no moment of nostalgia for the homeland, however oppressed or depressed it might have been? You don't think they felt a twinge of regret at having to leave the country that was THEIRS, the way America is yours, because for reasons beyond their control their country did not work? I am not pretending to imagine how harrowing life in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries was for immigrant Americans. But to me it is more fun and worthwhile to try to envision it and put myself into that extremely complex human experience, rather than to beat immigrants current or historical over the head with our vaguely-defined concept of democracy, which Bush loves to flail around like a kid with a toy gun. Maybe it's because I'm not an angry person, but rather a curious one; and I worked with Mexican guys for a year on a horse farm in Virginia and found them to be neither misty-eyed naive patriots nor hard-nosed Mexican loyalists, but rather extremely brave, hard-working, practical young men dealing with the economic and social reality of their lives. So what if they don't stay forever -- if in their hearts they yearned to return to their families and their native land? I learned more working side-by-side with them (under our Christian owner to boot) than in all my multiculturalism classes in college. My biggest regret right now is that I socialize with a homogeneous group of white friends and do not have that old in-road of work to let me get to know other communities, even though they are right next door to me. The Mexicans, the blacks, the Haitians and Puerto Ricans. All with a different view on life than I could ever hope to have, unless I learn from them. People have always tended to stick with their own kind, to feel a deep longing for identification. I do it too, out of a kind of inertia. But there are two ways to go from that self-knowing: a) not to try to understand those who are different from you, and rather be suspicious and dismissive of them; or b) to try to find an in-road. Multiculturalism is NOT about stressing differences (good word there - stress), but about being aware and curious about differences. Sensitive, not stressful. America IS a great land because we have the theoretically greatest ability to do just that. It is a disappointing land because we do not take advantage of that. In theory, we were founded on multiculturalism (even if, like the Greeks, the Founding Fathers were thinking mostly of white males when they said everyone could vote). It is a tricky, tortuous, slippery and fascinating road; and the way to negotiate it is carefully, curiously, not by barreling down and roaring that your way is best.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member